Is it Time for Recreational Anglers to Act?

 

Striped Bass

This article in Forbes Magazine calls for recreational anglers to limit their catch.

… And now, it seems, these fish, valued by both recreational and commercial fishermen, are in some serious danger…again. Back in the 1970s, thanks mainly to overharvesting, the striped bass population crashed to the point of near no-return. Thanks to the efforts of fishermen’s groups and the U.S. Congress (gasp!) in the late 1970s, the stocks recovered from a low of just under 5 million to 56 million in 2006. The economic impact of the striped bass recreational fishery is believed to be $6.5 billion.

 

That’s the good news. The bad news is that we seem to heading back toward those dark days in the 1970s again. And this time, the government agencies have decided to do nothing… Stripers Forever, says there has been “a decline of approximately 90 percent in the coast-wide recreational catch of wild stripers since 2006.”

Ninety percent decline, but ASMFC sees no immediate problems, and decides to wait.

But the government agency in charge of managing stocks of striped bass sees no immediate threat. Though the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission (ASMFC), in most recent stock status, found the striped bass to be in a continual decline since 2004 and well below its spawning target levels, the agency has decided to wait until 2015 to address the problem, which Burns says will be “too little, too late.”

 

To be sure, some changes are needed on the commercial striped bass fishery side. Paul Diodati, the Massachusetts Director of Fisheries, has suggested a 38% reduction in the commercial harvest.

 

But with the government set on inaction, it’s time for recreational anglers to step up and take their own measures. After all, much of the overfishing is from the recreational side of the equation. Stripers Forever says there are currently 10,000 commercial striped bass fishermen. There are 3 million recreational striped bass fisherman, and they take 60% of the harvest. The bag limit in many states is two fish a day of over 28 inches. Diodati has also suggested that the harvest be cut to one fish a day for recreational anglers, which seems very sensible.

 

But we can’t wait around for government regulations this time. For the next two years, all recreational anglers should consider limiting their catches to one keeper a day at a minimum (all catch-and-release would be better, in my opinion). This means self-imposed limits for anglers who fish from charter boats and from jetties and the beach. But it also means limits for those who go out on so-called “party boats.” Not to pick on party boat captains (these guys are operating within the rules—most of the time, anyway), but these boats seem to me to be a big part of the problem. The fishing from these boats, filled with 25 to 100 anglers all taking their two-fish-a-day limit, is just not sustainable. These captains have to know somewhere in their hearts that what they are doing is similar to the actions of the commercial fishermen who eventually fished cod out to the point of near extinction. Catching and killing that many striped bass on every trip is just not in their long term self-interest.

 

Striped Bass Scary Decline

This article in the Vineyard Gazette was published almost three years ago.

A drastic decline in striped bass stocks has state and federal officials scrambling to protect the fish, but many recreational fishermen say the government isn’t moving fast enough.

“It’s really scary,” said Cooper (Coop) Gilkes 3rd, owner of Coop’s Bait and Tackle shop in Edgartown, who has seen the haul from the annual June catch-and-release striper tournament fall dramatically. “At one point we had somewhere between 1,500 and 2,000 fish weighed in on one night. Last year there were 100 and it’s like a staircase going all the way down to last year. It’s just dropped every year.”

Last year, Mr. Gilkes said the annual springtime sea worm hatch in the Island’s coastal ponds — an event that historically attracts stripers by the hundreds — had “just about failed” after years of under-performance.

“It’s mind-boggling that we could get to this point with everybody watching,” he said.

The situation since the article was published is the same or worse, and everyone is still watching.   How much longer is this paralysis going to last?

 

Cinder Worm Program

Dave's Striper

Dave Pollack

Ray Stachelek and Dave Pollack are again facilitating the Cinder Worm program at USF&W’s Kettle Pond Nature Center.  This year we will instruct in fly tying on Tuesday, April 29 and Monday, May 5, and fish those flies at Ninigret on Saturday, May 10.  There is no charge for the program, and all necessary fly tying materials are provided. Fly tying tools, and fly rods, reels and line, will be provided to novices, without charge,  on request.
If you are interested in participating as a student, registration will be necessary, and important, because the program is limited to 40 students and fills up fast.  A formal announcement with registration information will be published in a month or so. Mark your calendars.
ConnRI, Rhody Fly Rodders, UFTRI, TU and RISAA members have been especially generous in the past in mentoring at the fly tying sessions and helping out at the fishing session. We’d like to enlist at least 12 instructors for the fly tying sessions.  If you are interested in helping out as an instructor this year, please contact David at Dpollipo@cox.net or Ray at castaflycharters@cox.net.  As usual USF&W and RIDEM will provide tools, materials and tackle, and so if you’d like us to have any particular hooks or fly tying materials available at the tying sessions let us know now.  We’d had a lot of fun at these sessions in the past, and we look forward to seeing our friends at the program this year.  Let’s hope that the worms and the fish  are even more cooperative this year than they were in 2013.

Dave Pollack

Brewster Flats in June

IMG_2281

I’m planning on fishing the Brewster Flats Wed-Sun, June 4-8.  It’s a fun place to sight fish for stripers. Anyone interested in joining me for one or more days, let me know by contacting me here - I will send you the directions and details.

Martin